The internet is buzzing with inexpensive (and sometimes free) AI tools that promise “professional” headshots at a fraction of the cost of a real photo session. At first glance, this might sound appealing—who wouldn’t want to save time and money? But when you dig deeper, you’ll see why these AI-generated headshots simply can’t replace the authenticity and quality provided by a professional headshot photographer.

An image generated by Adobe Photoshop AI. While having attributes of high-quality photography, the image looks uncanny and disturbing.

What Is an AI Headshot Service?

An AI headshot service typically involves you uploading a selfie or photo of yourself. The AI then “enhances” or outright recreates your appearance, producing a polished (and often heavily altered) headshot. It might swap backgrounds, adjust lighting, or even change facial features. While the tech can be impressive, it also raises questions about whether the final image is a genuine representation of you.

The Importance of Communicating Authenticity

The core reason for having a real headshot—versus an AI version—is to convey authenticity. As a professional photographer, my job isn’t just about showing the “truth,” but rather the truest version of who you are: knowledgeable, personable, and capable. A genuine photo session brings out these characteristics in a way AI tools can’t.

When someone encounters an AI-generated headshot, the question naturally arises: “Is this person real?” If your photo isn’t authentic, it casts doubt on your credibility. The power of an honest image cannot be overstated—particularly in a world where first impressions happen almost instantly.

The concept of “rotational Weight”

In building a racecar, an engineer tries to save weight wherever she can. But not all weight savings are equal. Racecars have skimpy aluminum wheels because that rotating mass is especially critical—those savings multiply when the wheels spin. Your headshot works like that “rotational weight.” When people interact with you online, they see your headshot over and over; it’s constantly communicating who you are. That’s why having an authentic-looking headshot is vital for achieving your career and business goals. You want it to be as optimized as possible so it can pay dividends every time someone views it.

Why a Professional Photographer Matters

Many people assume a professional camera is what defines a pro photographer. In reality, it’s the combination of posing guidance, high-end lighting, and a reliable workflow that sets professionals apart. Here’s how each factor helps you:

Guided Posing – A skilled photographer will direct you into poses that flatter your features and capture your true personality.
Expert Lighting Setup – Proper lighting can minimize shadows and highlight your best qualities.
Streamlined Process – Headshot photographers have efficient workflows that save you time and stress.

Surprisingly, professional headshot sessions can be quite affordable. I personally charge only $125 for a single headshot, which is far from a financial burden considering the opportunities a strong photo can unlock.

Opportunity Cost: What Are You Really Saving?

Yes, with the rising cost of living, saving $50 or $100 on a headshot service sounds tempting. But consider the concept of opportunity cost. A headshot can be your first—and maybe only—chance to make a positive impression. In a split second, viewers form an opinion of who you are based solely on your photo.

An AI headshot that looks off or inauthentic can undermine your credibility and cost you infinitely more—missed job offers, lost client relationships, or diminished trust. These potential setbacks easily outweigh the small upfront savings of using an AI service.

The Power of First Impressions

Human beings rely heavily on visual cues. The moment someone sees your photo, they start forming judgments. This is your headshot’s true role: to instantly communicate confidence, approachability, and professionalism. Given how crucial that is, do you really want to gamble your future on a quick AI filter?

Conclusion: Invest in Authenticity

So, should you get an AI headshot? The short answer is no. While AI services promise convenience and budget-friendly solutions, they can’t compete with the genuine representation and professional polish a real headshot photographer provides. First impressions are vital, and your headshot should be a true reflection of who you are.

In a world where everyone is vying for attention, an authentic headshot sets you apart. Don’t risk sending the wrong message with an AI-generated image. Instead, invest in yourself and your professional future by choosing a real headshot that truly does you justice.

Should I Get an AI Headshot? No!